If you’re self-employed, you’re responsible for paying SECA (self-employment tax), which covers your Social Security and Medicare obligations. But how does that compare to FICA taxes paid by traditional employees?

Spoiler alert: If you work for yourself, you pay double what traditional employees do.

Here’s everything you need to know to stay compliant, calculate your tax bill, and avoid surprises come tax season.

📌 Key Takeaways

  • ✅ The self-employment tax (SECA) rate is 15.3%, covering Social Security and Medicare.
  • ✅ FICA taxes apply to employees and are split between the employer and employee.
  • ✅ Self-employed individuals pay the full SECA amount but can deduct half of it on their tax return.
  • ✅ Understanding the difference between SECA and FICA helps self-employed individuals plan for tax season.

Understanding self-employment tax (SECA)

Self-employment tax is a tax that individuals who work for themselves must pay. Unlike traditional employees who have FICA taxes deducted from their paychecks, self-employed individuals are responsible for calculating and paying their own taxes. This can create a lot of confusion, but it is essential to know how SECA works.

What Is the self-employment tax (SECA)?

Self-employment tax primarily consists of Social Security and Medicare taxes. If you earn money through a business, freelance work, or any self-employed endeavor, you're likely subject to SECA.

🔎 Self employment tax rate

  • Total Rate: 15.3%
  • Social Security: 12.4% (on earnings up to the annual limit)
  • Medicare: 2.9% (no income limit)

💡 Pro Tip: Self-employed individuals pay both the employee and employer portions of these taxes, which is why the SECA rate is higher.

It’s important to remember that these taxes help fund important programs such as Social Security benefits, which many people rely on during retirement, and Medicare health insurance for older adults. By paying SECA, self-employed individuals contribute to their future financial security. Additionally, understanding the implications of SECA can empower self-employed individuals to make informed decisions about their financial planning, ensuring they set aside enough funds to cover their tax obligations while also investing in their business growth.

Calculation of SECA taxes

Calculating SECA can be straightforward. First, you need to determine your net earnings from self-employment. This is generally done by subtracting your business expenses from your total earnings. Pretty straight forward, right? 

Once you have your net earnings, you can apply the 15.3% tax rate.

Let's look at an example:

  • Earnings: $70,000
  • Business Expenses: $10,000
  • Mileage Deduction: $7,500
  • Net Earnings: $52,500

    Now we simply take that $52,500 and multiply it by the 15.3% tax rate. ($52,500 x 0.153) and get
    $8,032.50 in SECA tax

This means you would owe $8,032 in self-employment taxes for the year. Furthermore, it’s essential to note that half of your self-employment tax can be deducted from your taxable income when you file your federal tax return.

This deduction can help reduce your overall tax burden, making it crucial for self-employed individuals to keep accurate records of their earnings and expenses throughout the year.

Who pays self employment tax?

Anyone who earns money through self-employment must pay SECA. This includes freelancers, independent contractors, and business owners.

Even if you make a part-time income through a side business, you may still be responsible for SECA if your net earnings surpass $400 in a year.

It's crucial to keep track of your income and expenses throughout the year. Doing so ensures you are prepared when tax season arrives and that you accurately calculate the amount of SECA you owe. Being organized with your financial records can provide insights into your business performance, allowing you to identify trends and make strategic decisions that could enhance your profitability. Many self-employed individuals find it beneficial to use accounting software or hire a tax professional to assist with these calculations and ensure compliance with tax regulations.

What is FICA tax?

FICA stands for Federal Insurance Contributions Act. FICA taxes consist of two parts: Social Security and Medicare. The Social Security tax applies to income up to a certain limit, which adjusts annually. Income above this threshold is not subject to Social Security tax but will still incur Medicare tax at the same 1.45% rate.

This distinction is crucial for higher earners, as it can significantly affect their overall tax burden and future benefits.FICA taxes are automatically withheld from your paycheck, which is one of the key differences from self-employment tax.

FICA tax rates and calculation

🔎 FICA tax rates

  • Employee Contribution: 7.65% total
    • Social Security: 6.2% (up to $160,200 in earnings for 2023)
    • Medicare: 1.45% (no income limit)
  • Employer Contribution: 7.65% total (matches the employee portion)
  • Total FICA Tax Rate: 15.3% combined (employee + employer)

💡 Pro Tip: For employees, the FICA tax is automatically deducted from paychecks. Self-employed individuals pay both portions through SECA.

Together, as you can see, the total FICA tax is also 15.3%, the same as SECA. The difference? Employees only pay half, while self-employed individuals cover the full amount.

So from our example of a $70,000 earner from above, the employee would only pay $4,016.25, while their employer covered the rest.

Comparing SECA and FICA taxes

At their core, both SECA and FICA contribute to the same programs, namely Social Security and Medicare. They each play a vital role in funding benefits that people leverage as they age. These programs are essential for providing financial support and healthcare coverage to millions of Americans, ensuring that they can maintain a decent standard of living in their retirement years. The contributions made through these taxes are not just numbers on a paycheck; they represent a safety net that many rely on when they can no longer work.

Moreover, both taxes have similar rates. The self-employment tax combines Social Security and Medicare rates to total 15.3%, while the FICA tax, when accounting for both employee and employer contributions, totals 15.3% as well. This uniformity in rates highlights the shared responsibility of funding these critical programs, regardless of employment status. However, it’s important to note that the income cap for Social Security taxes can affect how much individuals ultimately contribute, leading to disparities in benefits received based on earnings.

📊 SECA vs. FICA Tax Comparison (2024)

Category SECA (Self-Employed) FICA (Employees)
Who Pays? Self-employed individuals pay both portions (employee + employer). Employees pay half, and their employers match the other half.
Total Tax Rate 15.3% 15.3% combined (7.65% from employee + 7.65% from employer)
Social Security Tax 12.4% (part of the 15.3% SECA rate) 6.2% from employee + 6.2% from employer
Medicare Tax 2.9% (part of the 15.3% SECA rate) 1.45% from employee + 1.45% from employer
Income Cap for Social Security Tax $168,600 (for 2024; adjusts annually) $168,600 (for 2024; adjusts annually)
Additional Medicare Tax 0.9% on earnings above $200,000 (single) or $250,000 (married) 0.9% on earnings above $200,000 (single) or $250,000 (married)
How It’s Paid Paid through quarterly estimated tax payments and at year-end. Automatically deducted from each paycheck.
Tax Deduction You can deduct 50% of SECA tax from your taxable income. No deduction for employees (employers can deduct their portion).

💡 Pro Tip: Self-employed individuals should set aside enough funds throughout the year to cover their SECA obligations and avoid surprises at tax time!

Impact on self employed individuals vs. employed Individuals

Self-employed individuals often face higher tax rates due to the nature of SECA. However, they may also qualify for certain deductions that help offset these costs, such as business expenses and the ability to deduct half of the self-employment tax from their taxable income.

This ability to deduct expenses related to their business can be a significant advantage, allowing them to reduce their overall taxable income and potentially lowering their tax burden. Additionally, self-employed individuals have the flexibility to choose their retirement savings plans, which can also provide tax benefits.

On the other hand, employed individuals benefit from paycheck deductions, simplifying the tax process for them. Still, their FICA taxes ensure they’re contributing towards their future Social Security and Medicare benefits, preserving their financial security down the line.

This automatic deduction can often go unnoticed, but it plays a crucial role in their long-term financial planning. Furthermore, employees may have access to employer-sponsored retirement plans, which can enhance their savings strategy and provide additional tax advantages that self-employed individuals may not have access to, creating a more straightforward path to retirement savings.

Self-employed tax obgliations

Managing taxes can be especially tricky for the self-employed. There are several strategies that can help ease the burden of SECA obligations and ensure compliance.

Tips for managing SECA obligations

First and foremost, it is vital to keep accurate records of your income and expenses. This includes invoices, receipts, and any relevant documents. Using accounting software or hiring a bookkeeper can simplify this process. Maintaining organized records not only helps during tax season but also provides a clear picture of your business's financial health throughout the year. Regularly reviewing your financial statements can help you identify trends, manage cash flow, and make informed decisions about future investments.

Another essential tip is to make estimated quarterly tax payments to avoid a tax bill shock during tax season. By setting aside funds throughout the year and making these payments, you’ll be better prepared when it’s time to file your annual return. Additionally, consider opening a separate bank account dedicated to tax savings. This way, you can easily track how much you’ve set aside for taxes and avoid the temptation to use those funds for other expenses.

Potential tax deductions and credits

Self-employed individuals may also take advantage of several tax deductions that can lower their overall tax liability. Some common deductions include:

  • Business expenses
    • Office supplies
    • Marketing expenses
    • Business mileage
  • Health insurance premiums
  • Home office deductions

Consulting a tax professional can provide insight into potential deductions and help navigate complex tax rules. Furthermore, it’s important to stay informed about any changes in tax legislation that could impact your deductions. For instance, the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act introduced new rules that affect how home office deductions are calculated, making it crucial for self-employed individuals to stay updated on these developments to optimize their tax strategy.

Seeking professional tax advice

Finally, don't hesitate to seek professional tax advice. A tax advisor with experience in working with self-employed individuals can give you tailored advice and ensure you’re compliant with tax regulations. They can help you navigate SECA effectively and maximize your deductions. Moreover, a knowledgeable tax advisor can assist you in strategic tax planning, helping you to not only minimize your current tax burden but also prepare for future financial goals. They can provide insights on retirement plans, such as SEP IRAs or Solo 401(k)s, which can offer significant tax advantages while also securing your financial future.

Preparing for Future Tax Obligations

Overall, understanding both SECA and FICA is essential for anyone paying these taxes. As life changes, staying proactive about tax obligations can lead to better financial management and reduced anxiety around tax season.

Self-employment tax and FICA taxes serve similar purposes, but the methods of payment, rates, and responsibilities differ vastly. No matter your employment situation, being informed and prepared can ensure a smoother path through the complicated world of taxes. Moreover, seeking advice from tax professionals or utilizing tax software can provide additional insights into optimizing tax strategies and ensuring compliance with evolving tax regulations. This proactive approach not only safeguards against unexpected liabilities but also enhances financial literacy, equipping individuals to navigate the complexities of their financial futures with confidence.

Pay Less Taxes This Year

Working for yourself? Tracking your income, mileage, and expenses is essential to making sure you don't pay more than you have to. Everlance has helped over 3.5 million independent workers do just that.

Download Now
  1. How does Everlance work?